NOVEMBER 20 — Hilaire Barnett’s Constitutional and Administrative Law is a book that has been trusted over generations, equipping its readers with a thorough understanding of the United Kingdom (UK)’s constitutional and administrative law. It is an indispensable guide to this complex area of the law.

On the constitutional concept and convention of collective responsibility, the Senior Lecturer in Law at Queen Mary & Westfield College, University of London explains as follows:

“The convention of collective Cabinet responsibility emphasises the unanimity of government and its accountability to Parliament. The classic expression of collective responsibility remains that of Lord Salisbury:

For all that passes in Cabinet every member of it who does not resign is absolutely and irretrievably responsible and has no right afterwards to say that he agreed in one case to a compromise, while in another he was persuaded by his colleagues… It is only on the principle that absolute responsibility is undertaken by every member of the Cabinet, who, after a decision is arrived at, remains a member of it, that the joint responsibility of Ministers to Parliament can be upheld and one of the essential principles of parliamentary responsibility established.

“The rationale for the convention lies in the need for government to present a united front to Parliament and the public in order to maintain confidence. A government which exhibits public disagreements over policy matters is one which will be regarded as weak, and will be subjected to challenges to its authority to continue in office.

“Two principal sub-rules underlie collective responsibility. The first rule is that, once an agreement is reached in Cabinet, all Members of Cabinet … are bound to speak in support of the decision. There should be no criticism or dissent from the decision in public — irrespective of whether or not the particular member of Cabinet was party to the discussion.

“Equally, if a decision is reached by the Prime Minister in Cabinet Committee or the Inner Cabinet when only a small handful of Members are present, the decision binds all.

“The second supporting rule is that records of Cabinet discussions are absolutely secret. The knowledge that Cabinet records are protected by confidentiality, enhances the opportunity for Members of Cabinet to discuss matters freely, secure in the knowledge that their personal point of view, whatever the decision, will be protected from the public gaze.

“These principles are expressed in ‘Questions of Procedure for Ministers’ in the following manner:

Collective responsibility requires that Ministers should be able to express their views frankly in the expectation that they can argue freely in private while maintaining a united front when decisions have been reached. This in turn requires that the privacy of opinions expressed in Cabinet and Ministerial Committees should be maintained. Moreover, Cabinet and Committee documents will often contain information which needs to be protected in the national interest. It is therefore essential that Ministers take the necessary steps to ensure that they and their staff preserve the privacy of Cabinet business and protect the security of government documents.”

A general view of the Prime Minister’s office in Putrajaya. — AFP pic
A general view of the Prime Minister’s office in Putrajaya. — AFP pic

In simple words, collective responsibility means that Ministers must, like the three musketeers, act ‘all for one, and one for all’ failing which they must resign.

The above is also stated by the great scholar, observer, popular teacher and good friend of Malaysia, Professor RH Hickling in An Introduction to the Federal Constitution, where the learned author said:

“It is this principle of collective responsibility that constitutes the most peculiar feature of what we call Cabinet government. All the Ministers are collectively responsible to Parliament, and if one of them refuses to accept the views of his colleagues, then he is expected to resign: for the Ministers stand or fall together.

“This is, in effect, an illustration of the principle of the rule of the majority, or what is sometimes called ‘government by consent’ in which those who disagree with the majority are nevertheless expected to accept their views.

“This, also, is the reason for the secrecy surrounding meetings of the Cabinet, and the brevity of Cabinet minutes, that is, the records of meetings of the Cabinet: for once policy has been decided by the Cabinet, it must be defended in Parliament by all members of the Cabinet.

“Ministers are, therefore, in the position of Dumas’ three musketeers: they must act ‘all for one, and one for all’, and if they fail to conform to this high ideal they must resign.”

* This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.