PETALING JAYA, Nov 19 — Putrajaya has several ways to safeguard Malaysia’s dual 5G model beyond its golden share in Digital Nasional Bhd (DNB), including legislation and conditions attached to spectrum assignments, says an industry expert.

Jake Saunders, vice-president for Asia at technology intelligence firm ABI Research, said the government’s golden share already provides one safeguard.

“The Malaysian government does have its Golden Share in DNB, which gives the Malaysian government a vital say in the future endeavours of DNB,” he said.

However, Saunders said different policy instruments offered different strengths if Putrajaya wanted to preserve Malaysia’s access to separate technology ecosystems over the longer term.

“It is a complex topic. Legislation is a very durable solution; ministerial direction is always beneficial and can help direct and galvanise government agencies,” he said.

“Going further, setting out spectrum conditions/ assignments can be more hardcoded. That is, set rights of access and/or limitations on transfers that can also applied for a guaranteed duration of time.”

Saunders said maintaining access to a wide range of technologies was important as geopolitical developments, mergers and acquisitions could gradually narrow the options available to countries.

“Throughout history, technology innovation has always accelerated in the most open and most diverse markets, and yet mergers & acquisition as well as geo-politics over time can inevitability constrain options.”

He said Malaysia was well placed to benefit from technologies emerging from both China and Western-aligned economies.

“Malaysia has always been at the crossroads of Asia and the rest of the world, and it would be prudent that the widest possible access to technologies — such as chipsets, smart devices, infrastructure hardware, for data centres, cellular networks, AI R&D and implementation — is kept open,” he added.

“Offering a dual technology stack, or lane, would ensure DNB and indeed the wider Malaysian economy has competitive access to all technologies, the wider technology ecosystem and its opportunities.”

DNB currently operates one of Malaysia’s two wholesale 5G networks, while U Mobile has been selected to operate the second network. DNB’s network was built by Ericsson, while U Mobile is being supported by Huawei and ZTE.

The government is also transferring ownership of DNB to CelcomDigi, Maxis and YTL, although Putrajaya retains its golden share.

Switching technologies not straightforward

Saunders said DNB could technically change parts of its network technology over time, but replacing an established 5G system would involve more than simply changing equipment.

In 2021, Ericsson signed a 10-year contract with DNB that covers an end-to-end network encompassing the core network, radio access network, transport systems, operations and business support systems, and managed services.

Saunders said there was greater flexibility in the radio access network, where base stations and antennas could be replaced, although even this was not straightforward.

“RAN base-stations and antennas could be swapped out but there would still need to be additional network planning, equipment testing, debugging and integration.”

He said Ericsson also supported DNB’s operations layer through a dedicated network operations centre covering functions such as billing, faults, network performance and security. A complete replacement would therefore carry additional costs and operational complications.

“A full-on swap out would certainly incur additional capital expenditure, ongoing integration costs, and longer-term debugging and network performance testing.”

Saunders said there were also legal and financial considerations, including vendor financing, compliance with contractual milestones and support arrangements.

He said DNB could nevertheless change its technology gradually rather than through a single wholesale replacement.

Separately, Saunders said DNB would need to continue innovating following the handover, particularly as Malaysia develops its industrial automation and artificial intelligence capabilities.

He said future upgrades could include newer radios at base stations in high-traffic urban areas, RedCap technology to support lower-cost devices and industrial internet-of-things applications, and greater use of available spectrum to increase capacity.