What You Think
Why green transport needs the circular economy — Ahmad Ibrahim
NOVEMBER 20 — The world has bet heavily on electrification to clean up transport. It is working — up to a point. But a narrow focus on tailpipe emissions is leading us into a new trap: as vehicles go electric, their carbon footprint is migrating upstream, to the mines, smelters, and factories that produce steel, aluminum, and batteries.The numbers are stark. Supply chain emissions already account for roughly 20 per cent of a light-duty vehicle’s lifecycle footprint, and that figure is projected to climb to 60–70 per cent as electrification scales. Battery cells alone represent nearly a third of a battery electric vehicle’s supply chain emissions. In other words, the better we get at zero-emission driving, the more material-intensive — and carbon-embedded — production becomes.This is not an argument against electric vehicles. It is an argument for completing the strategy. Green transport without circularity risks trading a tailpipe problem for a mining and manufacturing problem. Circular economy practices without green transport lack the scale and policy momentum to transform mobility. Neither can deliver deep sustainability alone.The good news is that the tools exist, and they span the entire vehicle lifecycle.Upstream, designing for disassembly and material recovery determines whether a vehicle at end-of-life becomes waste or a resource. The automotive sector consumes 12 per cent of global steel demand — 17 per cent in the EU — making low-emissions steel procurement a high-leverage intervention. Offtake agreements for green steel grew 22 per cent year-over-year, with automakers the strongest source of demand pull. Circular procurement, in other words, can drive industrial transformation.Midstream, the conventional model treats vehicle retirement as a fixed endpoint. Circular practices challenge that assumption. GIGA, a French battery repair centre, reports that 99 per cent of arriving battery packs are repairable, with faulty cells replaced rather than entire packs discarded. Remanufacturing components like gearboxes and traction motors can cut waste by 70 per cent, energy use by 80 per cent, and water usage by 88 per cent compared with new production. For fleet operators with centralised maintenance, these are not niche opportunities — they are operational imperatives.Downstream, batteries that no longer meet automotive standards often retain 70–80 per cent of capacity and can serve stationary energy storage. Modeling of China’s electric vehicle fleet shows that second-life battery use and recycling together can significantly reduce demand for virgin materials. At end-of-life, recycling recovers lithium, cobalt, and nickel that would otherwise require new extraction.Yet circular value creation is context-dependent. Indonesia’s electric motorcycle ecosystem faces dependence on imported raw materials, limited domestic recycling capacity, and no sector-specific extended producer responsibility framework. France’s EPR scheme for end-of-life vehicles offers a model, but such measures remain disparate without an overarching framework linking circularity to transport decarbonisation. Malaysia’s launch of Asean’s first EV Battery Passport — mandating lifecycle transparency — shows what institutionalising traceability looks like.Several tensions warrant honesty. Circularity has physical limits: as production scales, scrap availability cannot meet total demand for automotive-grade materials. In many emerging economies, end-of-life management occurs through informal networks difficult to regulate. And our modeling tools remain too coarse to capture cross-sector linkages and macroeconomic feedbacks, leaving policymakers without adequate guidance.There are distributional consequences too. France’s €50 million retraining programme for cast-metal auto parts workers acknowledges that industrial transformation has a human dimension. Green sukuk and sustainability taxonomies offer financial instruments to channel capital toward circular transport infrastructure. The EU’s just transition mechanism aims to keep new mobility affordable across regions and passenger groups.What emerges is a convergent pathway, not a choice between strategies. Green transport provides the demand signal, policy urgency, and technological momentum. Circular economy practices provide the material efficiency, lifecycle thinking, and resource resilience that electrification alone cannot deliver. Together, they address the full spectrum of transport’s footprint — from mine to tailpipe to scrapyard.This requires policy coherence across domains that have traditionally operated separately: energy, industry, waste, and mobility. It requires measurement frameworks that capture lifecycle and system-wide effects rather than isolated interventions. And it requires context-sensitive implementation — what works for Norway’s mature EV market differs from Indonesia’s emerging two-wheeler ecosystem, and both differ from Malaysia’s logistics sector, where Pos Malaysia has deployed over 1,250 electric bikes while confronting the persistent challenge of finding partners who can deliver viable solutions at suitable prices.The integration of green transport and circular economy is not a technical add-on. It is a fundamental reframing of how mobility is produced, used, and recovered — a shift from managing emissions at the point of use to stewarding materials across multiple lifecycles. The pathways exist. The task now is to build the institutional, financial, and behavioral architectures that let them converge.* Professor Datuk Dr Ahmad Ibrahim is affiliated with the Tan Sri Omar Centre for STI Policy Studies at UCSI University and is an Adjunct Professor at the Ungku Aziz Centre for Development Studies, Universiti Malaya. He can be reached at ahmadibrahim@ucsiuniversity.edu.my.** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.

Related Articles

 

You May Also Like