NOVEMBER 16 — The results of the Melaka state election on 14 November 2026 dealt another blow to Pakatan Harapan (PH), after the coalition secured only four of the 28 State Legislative Assembly (DUN) seats contested. More concerningly, all four seats were won by DAP, while PKR and Amanah failed to win a single seat.
In an election in which Barisan Nasional (BN) won 21 seats and Perikatan Nasional (PN) secured three, the BN-PN alliance controlled 24 of the 28 DUN seats. PH not only failed to expand its influence, but also lost one seat compared with the five it won in the 2021 state election.
These results should be viewed as going beyond the question of winning or losing a state election. They raise a broader question about PH’s position in the national political landscape, particularly its ability to retain voter support ahead of the 16th General Election (GE16).
Post-truth politics and the crisis of perception
Politics today no longer depends solely on policy achievements or economic figures. Perceptions of government performance are often shaped by social media, digital content, political narratives and people’s everyday experiences.
In a post-truth political environment, perceptions and emotions can have a greater influence than facts in shaping the political positions of some voters. This does not mean that voters are irrational. Rather, the information they receive, their level of trust in institutions and their personal experiences all play a role in determining how a particular policy is evaluated.
The government may have achievements in macroeconomic performance, investment and international relations. However, if these achievements are not felt in people’s daily lives, they may fail to translate into political confidence. In this context, PH needs to distinguish between successfully implementing policies and successfully convincing the public of their effectiveness. These are two different things.
Political cooperation does not necessarily translate into voter loyalty
Another important question concerns PH’s ability to retain voter support amid an increasingly complex political landscape. Political cooperation between parties that once competed directly is not easily translated into support at the ballot box. A coalition may reach an agreement at leadership level, but supporters of the parties involved may not necessarily accept that decision.
This is important in understanding PH’s position after the Melaka state election. Some voters may remain loyal to particular parties, while others may make their decisions based on candidates, local issues or their assessment of the incumbent government.
In such circumstances, political cooperation formed out of the need to establish a government may face a legitimacy problem at the grassroots level. More importantly, cooperation between parties does not automatically result in the transfer of votes. A party’s supporters cannot be treated as an asset that can simply be transferred to a coalition partner through a leadership decision.
If PH’s defeat in Melaka also involved a failure to consolidate support among different voter groups, this issue must be taken seriously before negotiations over seat allocation for GE16 begin.
Malay voters and the challenge of rebuilding support
PH also needs to pay attention to its level of support among Malay voters. In recent years, Malaysian politics has seen increasingly intense competition to secure Malay voter support, particularly between the governing coalition and Perikatan Nasional (PN).
Voters’ choices are also influenced by economic factors, perceptions of leadership, confidence in political parties, integrity issues and a coalition’s ability to represent the voices of the community, alongside ethnic and religious considerations.
PH needs to acknowledge that forming the Federal government does not mean the coalition has resolved the challenge of securing political legitimacy among all segments of society. Failure to broaden its Malay support base could limit PH’s room for growth in future elections, particularly in mixed and semi-urban constituencies with more diverse voter compositions.
At the same time, PH should not assume that non-Malay voters will continue to support it automatically. Voter loyalty is not permanent and should never be treated as a guarantee of victory.
A coalition that wishes to remain relevant must build support across different segments of society, rather than merely defending its traditional strongholds.
Losing at state level does not necessarily mean losing at federal level
In comparative politics, electoral outcomes at state and national levels do not necessarily move in the same direction. This phenomenon can be understood through the concept of split-ticket voting, in which voters support different parties at different levels of an election.
Voters may choose a particular party to govern the state based on local issues, administrative performance or a candidate’s popularity, while supporting another party in a national election based on national leadership, the economy and foreign policy.
India’s experience provides a significant example. In December 2018, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) suffered major defeats in state elections in Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh. In Chhattisgarh, for example, the BJP won only 15 of the 90 seats, while the Indian National Congress (INP) won 68 seats and formed a government with a substantial majority.
However, only about six months later, the political landscape changed significantly. In India’s 2019 General Election, the National Democratic Alliance (NDA), a coalition of political parties, won 353 seats in the Lok Sabha (House of the People), of which 303 seats were won by the BJP, enabling Narendra Modi to remain as India’s Prime Minister for a second term.
This phenomenon demonstrates that defeat at the state level is not necessarily an absolute indicator of a party’s or coalition’s ability to win an election at the federal level. Nevertheless, this comparison does not mean that PH is guaranteed to replicate the same success. India’s political structure, party system and national leadership dynamics differ from those of Malaysia. The main lesson is that voters make different political calculations depending on the electoral context.
Political survival ahead of GE16
As GE16 approaches, PH must avoid the tendency to view every electoral defeat merely as a communications problem. It is possible that the real problem lies in the gap between voters’ expectations and the government’s performance.
First, PH needs to reassess the strengths of each component party within the coalition. Relations between DAP, PKR and Amanah should be built on complementary political capabilities, rather than merely on the allocation of electoral constituencies.
Second, the government needs to pay greater attention to issues that directly affect people’s lives. The cost of living, employment opportunities, household income, housing and social mobility are among the issues that can influence voters’ assessment of the government.
Third, PH needs to rebuild its relationship with voters outside urban areas. Winning in several urban constituencies is not enough to ensure political sustainability at the national level. A coalition that wishes to remain in government must have broader appeal across regions and demographic groups.
Fourth, PH needs to shift its political communication approach from being overly defensive towards one that places greater emphasis on explanation and problem-solving. The government cannot rely solely on the argument that the country is in a better position than it was under the previous administration.
Instead, the government needs to explain what has been achieved, what has yet to be delivered and how outstanding problems will be addressed. Ultimately, the question of PH’s political survival ahead of GE16 is not simply whether the coalition can retain Putrajaya. The more important question is whether PH still has the ability to offer the people hope, confidence and a convincing sense of direction.
* This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.