What You Think
Islam, humanity, and the Geneva Conventions — Phar Kim Beng and Shahiran Kamaruzaman
NOVEMBER 20 — Islam is projected to become the world’s largest religion by 2035, largely because Muslim populations are younger and have higher fertility rates, not primarily because of conversion. Pew Research Centre forecasts 2.57 billion Muslims and 2.52 billion Christians by 2035, with Muslim fertility averaging 3.1 children per woman from 2020–2025, compared with 2.5 for Christians.That demographic reality makes the protection of civilians, humanitarian access, and the rule of law more important, not less. The Geneva Conventions provide a shared legal floor for war as they protect people who are not fighting or can no longer fight, and they limit how armed conflicts may be conducted.Why Islam’s growth mattersIslam’s rise is fundamentally a demographic story. It is projected that Muslims will grow from 26 per cent to 36 per cent of the world’s population by 2035, while Christianity remains around 29 per cent. It should be noted that both religions are expected to keep growing, but Islam is growing faster.This does not mean that Muslim-majority societies will inevitably become more conflict-prone. Islam, like Christianity and other major faiths, contains strong traditions of mercy, justice, protection of the vulnerable, and restraint in warfare. The central challenge is political: ensuring that religious identity is not exploited by armed groups, authoritarian regimes, sectarian entrepreneurs, or foreign powers to justify violence.Why the Geneva Conventions matterThe four Geneva Conventions of 1949 are the core of international humanitarian law. They protect civilians, wounded and sick combatants, prisoners of war, medical personnel, and humanitarian workers; their Additional Protocols further regulate attacks and require parties to distinguish civilians from military targets.The core of the Conventions ultimately comprises of five key elements.The first element is Humanity. This requires protecting life, dignity, and both physical and mental integrity, grounded in fundamental guarantees of humane treatment under customary international law. It serves as a foundational baseline ensuring that even in extreme circumstances, basic human worth is preserved.The second element is Distinction, which demands that attacks be directed strictly at military objectives and never at civilians or civilian objects under the principle of distinction. Parties must actively separate combatants and military targets from non-combatants and everyday infrastructure.The third element is Proportionality and Precaution, which calls for avoiding excessive civilian harm relative to expected military advantage and taking feasible precautions prior to launching attacks, as codified in customary rules on proportionality and precautions in attack. Before any strike, planners must evaluate potential incidental damage and take practical steps to minimize risk to people and civilian property.The fourth element is Humane treatment. This strictly prohibits torture, hostage-taking, collective punishment, and execution carried out without a regular trial, obligations detailed across Common Articles 2 and 3 and Additional Protocol II. Anyone detained or otherwise under a party's control must be treated with basic decency and afforded due process.The fifth element is Accountability, which obligates authorities to pursue, try, or extradite individuals responsible for grave breaches. Violations cannot simply be ignored; there must be concrete legal follow-through against perpetrators, including through command responsibility and international criminal accountability.These rules matter because war does not suspend morality. Even in conflict, parties must care for the wounded, respect detainees, allow humanitarian relief, and spare civilians.Conflicts in the Muslim worldMany of today’s most visible wars and crises occur in or affect Muslim-majority societies, including conflicts involving state forces, insurgent groups, sectarian militias, foreign interventions, and disputes over territory or governance. But it is both inaccurate and dangerous to treat "the Muslim world” as a single bloc or to blame Islam itself for these conflicts. The common pattern is not religion alone. It is often weak institutions, contested legitimacy, foreign interference, economic inequality, authoritarian rule, armed non-state actors, and the weaponisation of sectarian or nationalist identity. In such settings, civilians bear the greatest cost: displacement, starvation, destroyed hospitals, detained families, and indiscriminate bombardment.A shared moral foundationIslamic ethics and the Geneva Conventions converge on a basic principle: the innocent must not pay the price of war. Islamic teachings emphasise the sanctity of life, mercy, justice, and protection of non-combatants; international humanitarian law translates comparable principles into binding legal duties.The Geneva Conventions are therefore important underpinnings for any future in which Muslims form a larger share of humanity. They provide a universal standard that applies regardless of religion, nationality, or political cause: civilians are not targets, prisoners retain dignity, medical workers must be protected, and those who commit atrocities must face consequences.What responsible leadership requiresResponsible leadership requires prioritising the protection of civilians above all else, even during complex sieges, urban warfare, and counterterrorism operations. It demands the preservation of humanitarian corridors, hospitals, and aid workers, alongside uninterrupted access to essential supplies like food, water, and medicine. Furthermore, leaders must firmly reject collective punishment and sectarian rhetoric that paint entire populations as enemies, while ensuring that any alleged war crimes are independently investigated and perpetrators are held accountable. Ultimately, responsible leadership means choosing diplomacy, inclusive political settlements, and reconstruction over endless military escalation.Islam’s growing global presence should be met with confidence in shared humanity, not fear. It should be noted that the strongest response to conflict in Muslim-majority societies is not collective suspicion, it is instead rigorous enforcement of the Geneva Conventions, respect for civilian life, and political solutions that address the causes of violence.*Phar Kim Beng, PhD, is Professor of Asean Studies at the International Islamic University Malaysia and Director of the Institute of International and Asean Studies (IINTAS). Shahiran Kamaruzaman is an independent legal researcher.** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.

Related Articles

 

You May Also Like