What You Think
Declassified minutes of Pardons Board meeting are to support the objection to the Malaysian Bar’s application for leave to initiate judicial review — Hafiz Hassan
NOVEMBER 20 — On November 12, it was reported that the Malaysian Bar has filed an application for leave to initiate a judicial review of the Federal Territories Pardons Board (FTPB)’s decision allowing former prime minister Datuk Seri Najib Tun Razak to serve the remainder of his prison sentence in the SRC International Sdn Bhd case under house arrest.The application was filed on November 10 at the Kuala Lumpur High Court, naming the Federal Territories Pardons Board, Minister in the Prime Minister’s Department (Law and Institutional Reform), Director-General of Prisons and Najib as respondents. The Bar is seeking a declaration that any proceedings or decision purportedly made under Articles 40 and 42 of the Federal Constitution is invalid in law and contradicts the Federal Constitution, and an order to quash the Pardons Board’s proceedings and decision, as well as an order for the house arrest of the former prime minister to be stayed immediately, should leave be granted, pending the outcome of the judicial review.Later on, on the same day, it was reported that the Attorney General’s Chambers (AGC) is objecting to the Bar’s application."Certainly, the Attorney General is objecting to this leave application because the impugned decision relates to the decision of the Yang di-Pertuan Agong in presiding over a Pardons Board meeting, which is non-justiciable,” Senior Federal Counsel Ahmad Hanir Hambaly@Arwi told High Court Judge S. Indra Nehru during the hearing of the leave application. Present at the hearing was lawyer Muhammad Farhan Muhammad Shafee, representing Najib, who told the court that his client, like the AGC, requested for time to file their respective written submissions.Senior lawyer, Zainur Zakaria, appearing for the Bar, did not object to the requests by the AGC and Najib’s counsel for time.The learned High Court Judge fixed March 17 next year for the hearing of the application and directed parties to file their respective written submissions by December 14, with replies to be filed by December 28.Yesterday, Free Malaysia Today (FMT) reported that the FTPB meeting minutes on Najib’s pardon application were declassified for inclusion in a court affidavit. A source familiar with the matter told FMT that the AGC was required to file the affidavit in reply to the Bar’s application ."The minutes were among the documents to be included, so they needed to be declassified. That was why it was done,” the source told FMT. As I wrote in "OSA: The principles of justice and transparency must also be upheld” there is no absolute bar to the production of a document that is privileged or classified under the OSA as evidence in court.Even if a document has been classified as an official secret, it does not mean that the document will be automatically or completely excluded from being produced as evidence in court. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has rightly alluded to the same. One has to be mindful that the declassified minutes of the meeting of the Pardons Board are in support of the AGC’s affidavit to object the Bar’s application for leave.Yes, to object to the Bar’s application which the AGC contends concerns a matter that is non-justiciable — that is, cannot be reviewed by the court.* This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.

Related Articles

 

You May Also Like