What You Think
No more horsing around with scams: They have to be wiped out in Asean writ large — Phar Kim Beng

FEBRUARY 17 — Japan’s decision to fund Southeast Asian efforts against cross-border crimes is not a minor development in regional cooperation.

It is a signal that the patience of Asia’s middle powers is wearing thin.

Tokyo has pledged more than five hundred million yen in grant assistance to strengthen investigative capabilities in Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam and Laos. The focus is clear: dismantling transnational scam syndicates that have metastasised across mainland Southeast Asia.

For years, these criminal networks have exploited weak borders, uneven policing standards and legal loopholes between Asean states.

The result has been an industry of deception — online fraud, call-centre scams, human trafficking and forced labour — operating across jurisdictions faster than governments can react.

Japan’s involvement shows that the problem has escaped the confines of domestic law enforcement. It is now a regional security threat.

A crime economy, not petty fraud 

Scam compounds are no longer isolated operations run by small gangs. They are industrialised enterprises.

Workers — often trafficked from across Asia — are forced to impersonate bank officers, police officers, investment advisers or romantic partners online.

The profits run into tens of billions of dollars annually.

Victims come not only from Southeast Asia but also Japan, South Korea, Australia, China, Europe and North America. Entire retirement savings vanish in hours. Families collapse under sudden debt. Psychological trauma follows financial ruin.

In effect, transnational scams have become Southeast Asia’s shadow export sector.

This is why police raids in Cambodia, Myanmar and neighbouring areas have intensified. But raids alone cannot solve the problem.

The networks simply relocate across borders overnight.

Asean’s greatest strength — open connectivity — has become its greatest vulnerability.

Japan steps in — quietly but significantly 

Japan’s grant assistance is small in monetary terms but large in strategic meaning.

Tokyo is not funding infrastructure or trade corridors this time. It is funding investigative capability.

That includes forensic training, digital tracing, intelligence sharing and coordinated policing standards.

In diplomatic language, this is capacity building. In practical terms, it is trust building.

Japan is effectively saying: economic partnership cannot deepen if criminal networks continue exploiting regional integration.

No investor, tourist or student will feel safe if Southeast Asia becomes synonymous with organised online fraud.

Why Asean must treat this as a security crisis 

For too long, scams have been viewed as a law-and-order issue.

They are not. They are a governance crisis.

These syndicates rely on three conditions:

Fragmented jurisdiction:

Corruption within enforcement structures

Lack of real-time intelligence sharing

As long as criminals can cross a border faster than police paperwork can move, they will win.

The reality is uncomfortable but undeniable: parts of mainland Southeast Asia have become operational safe zones for criminal syndicates because enforcement coordination has lagged behind economic integration.

Asean created free movement for goods, capital and people. Criminals simply globalised faster than regulators.

Beyond raids — toward regional policing 

The future must go beyond periodic crackdowns. What is required is permanent cooperative enforcement.

Asean already practices military exercises and disaster response coordination. The same institutional seriousness must now apply to transnational crime.

A regional investigative grid is needed — shared biometric databases, synchronised warrants, joint interrogation protocols and rapid extradition procedures.

Without this, criminals will continue playing jurisdictional ping-pong.

Japan’s support may become the template: external partners strengthening Asean’s enforcement backbone while respecting sovereignty.

Human cost must not be ignored 

Behind every scam operation lies another crime — human trafficking.

Thousands of young people are lured by fake job offers, only to be imprisoned inside scam compounds and forced to defraud strangers.

Those who refuse face violence.

This is modern slavery hidden behind digital screens.

Eradicating scams is therefore not only about protecting victims abroad. It is about rescuing victims within Southeast Asia itself.

The strategic stakes 

Asean aspires to be a central node of global supply chains and digital commerce. Yet digital trust is now the currency of economic credibility.

If the region gains a reputation as the world’s scam capital, financial technology development, cross-border payments and digital banking integration will suffer.

Investors tolerate political differences. They do not tolerate systemic fraud risk.

The credibility of Asean’s digital economy is now tied directly to its ability to eliminate organised scams.

In this file photo taken on February 23, 2025, alleged scam centre workers and victims stand together during a crackdown operation by the Karen Border Guard Force (BGF) on illicit activity, at the border checkpoint with Thailand in Myanmar’s eastern Myawaddy township. — AFP pic

A turning point 

Japan’s intervention should be seen as a polite warning from a long-time partner: regional prosperity cannot coexist with transnational criminal sanctuaries.

The issue is no longer embarrassment.

It is competitiveness.

If Southeast Asia wants to lead the Global South’s digital growth, it must guarantee digital safety.

No more horsing around 

The time for episodic crackdowns and public relations announcements is over.

What Asean needs now is sustained, coordinated enforcement — not for months but for years.

Scam syndicates are adaptive, well-financed and technologically sophisticated. Governments must be more so.

Japan has taken the first cooperative step. Asean must now institutionalise the response.

Because in the digital age, trust travels faster than trade.

And once trust is lost, prosperity follows it out the door.

No more horsing around. The scam industry must be wiped out — not nationally, but regionally — or it will keep returning, border by border, victim by victim.

* Phar Kim Beng is a professor of Asean Studies and director of the Institute of International and Asean Studies, International Islamic University of Malaysia.

** This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.

Related Articles

 

You May Also Like