What You Think
OSA: The principles of justice and transparency must also be upheld — Hafiz Hassan
NOVEMBER 19 — Umno information chief Datuk Seri Azalina Othman Said has rightly said that for documents with official secret status, the decision to declassify them must be made by the authority under Section 2C of the Official Secrets Act 1972 [Act 88] (OSA).Azalina, who is also minister for law and institutional reforms, has called for the relevant authorities to explain how the Federal Territories Pardons Board meeting minutes that discussed Datuk Seri Najib Razak’s conditional pardon had been made public. But Azalina, who is a lawyer by training, should know that there are instances when parties in court proceedings may have to rely on a document which is privileged or even classified as an official secret under the OSA.It is trite that there is no absolute bar to the production of a document that is privileged or classified under the OSA as evidence in court. It is within the powers of the court to determine the admissibility of such document. The Federal Court in the case of BA Rao &Ors v Sapuran Kaur & Anor as far back as 1978 had affirmed that it is the court, not the executive, that ultimately determines whether there is a real basis for the claim that "affairs of State is involved”, before it permits non-disclosure.Federal Court Judge Raja Azlan Shah (as he then was) said:"In this country, objection as to production as well as admissibility contemplated in ss. 123 and 162 of the Evidence Act is decided by the Court in an enquiry of all available evidence. This is because the court understands better than all others the process of balancing competing considerations. It has power to call for the documents, examine them, and determine for itself the validity of the claim."Unless the Court is satisfied that there exists a valid basis for assertion of the privilege, the evidence must be produced. This strikes a legitimate balance between the public and private interest."Where there is a danger that disclosure will divulge, say, State secrets in military and international affairs or Cabinet documents, or departmental policy documents, private interest must give way."It is for the Court, not the executive, ultimately to determine that there is a real basis for the claim that ‘affairs of State’ is involved, before it permits non-disclosure. While it is clear that the final decision in all circumstances rests with the Court, and that the Court is entitled to look at the evidence before reaching a concluded view, it can be expected that categories of information will develop from time to time."It is for that reason that the legislature has refrained from defining ‘affairs of State’. In my opinion, ‘affairs of State’, like an elephant, is perhaps easier to recognise than to define, and their existence must depend on the particular facts of each case.”The Federal Court Judge’s statements were referred to sixteen years later in the case of Takong Tabari (Suing in her personal capacity and as the Administratrix of the Estate of Jeffery Satuk Gabar-Deceased) v Government of Sarawak & 3 Ors [1994] where High Court Judge Richard Malanjum (as he then was) said:"[I]t must be recognised that the issue of admissibility of any piece of evidence in a Court of law in this country comes mainly within the purview of the Evidence Act 1950. I find nothing expressed or implied that the [OSA] should be taken as a statute governing admissibility of evidence."In my view the [OSA] deals mainly with the prevention of unauthorised disclosure of official secrets and thus [creates] offences for any such infringement. I do not think it is intended to be used to avoid any liability or to defeat any claim regardless of the culpability of the party relying on it."It is obvious that the primary goal of the [OSA] is to protect classified documents or information which by such disclosure would be detrimental to the national security or public interest.”In simple words, even if a document has been classified as an official secret, it does not mean that the document will be automatically or completely excluded from being produced as evidence in court. (See also the High Court decision in Rotta Research Laboratorium SPA & Anor v Ho Tack Sian & Ors [2015]).So, it is the court to determine whether there is a real basis to contend that the document concerns the affairs of the state or national security. In determining the admissibility of such document, the court will have to strike a balance between the public and private interests. The protection of national security and public interest is paramount.But the principles of justice and transparency must also be upheld.*This is the personal opinion of the writer or publication and does not necessarily represent the views of Malay Mail.

Related Articles

 

You May Also Like