Opinion
Despite writing on the wall, denial is rampant
NOVEMBER 19 — It’s gone wackadoodle for Pakatan Harapan. I assume, in their Melaka post-mortem session, the leaders all sat in a room and stared mindlessly at each other. No one dares ask, can it get worse?Maybe I misspeak, maybe they were mindful and attentive staring at each other in dread. Karipap was served. Either way, does it matter? They are staring into the abyss.Pakatan Harapan Election Director Amirudin Shari turned part poet, part philosopher when he spoke about coalitions in the new electoral realities, and that realignments are necessary like he worked on executive vehicles in an auto workshop rather than as the prime minister’s chief campaigner. And, oh yeah, there were noticeable improvements in votes in some segments, according to Amirudin.Here’s how it appears to the country.Amanah and PKR were trounced. Adly Zahari, the chief minister candidate managed to convince only one in three voters in Bukit Katil that he was worthy to represent the constituency, let alone lead the state. He lost to a novice PAS-PN candidate. A deputy minister and former chief minister defeated by a local council health director.Elsewhere, their candidates dropped like flies. Nowhere were they even close.DAP kept its four seats and lost massive ground in Duyong. Inexplicably transforming Kota Melaka into a marginal seat for the next general election.To imagine a silver lining let alone suggest it is ludicrous.This time, Pakatan cannot lay any blame on Bersama, its splinter. For BN-PN were not recipients of a vote split. They benefited from Pakatan’s more obvious frailty, its unattractiveness to voters.Don’t live in the muckWhat can Pakatan do?Not more of the same.Since local advice is not welcome, let’s give some Hollywood. Hannibal Lecter’s famous advice to Clarice Starling in The Silence of the Lambs, it won Oscars dammit.Notwithstanding the character’s cannibalism, the good doctor suggested reading Roman ruler Marcus Aurelius. "First principles, Clarice. Simplicity.” A lesson in Stoic reduction and radical analysis useful to Pakatan presently.It’s not going to win the general election by mimicking the BN-PN love fest. There’s a reason it works, for them. Umno and PAS, the base for the coalitions, work on race unity.They discard all other elements. Simplistic, sure, but clear. Easy to transmit to the masses and risks no misunderstanding. Everything pivots to the single idea.Omniscient fearmongers. Everything is dumbed down and they are masters at disengagement.Pakatan is the gathering of PKR, pieced together from reformasi Keadilan and social-democrats Parti Rakyat Malaysia with the bull logo; Amanah, a PAS splinter because it has democratic moderates; and, DAP, a schizophrenic party which bounces along to communal and democratic beats.The overall commitment to progressive values, reforms and anti-corruption zeal, even if more dressing than protein, binds them. Still, a solar system away from either BN or PN.Pakatan is complicated and flawed. It wins via relative messaging, not by identity. At least till 2022. These days, few recognise the coalition.The last desperate measure to strategic partner with an indeterminate Bersatu was a disaster.The whole Melaka experiment was doomed from the start. And even if values cannot be matched, what is Bersatu’s electoral worth? It’s crumbling with each election. Pakatan voters probably contributed to the 15,000 votes Bersatu garnered than the other way around.Be true to oneselfSimplicity is not the same as simplistic or oversimplification.In 2057, Malaysia would be 100 and even more multicultural than today. It’s a future Pakatan is more suited to than BN-PN. Say that. Over and over. One coalition is of the past and the other of the future.Pakatan should embrace its multiculturalism and not compete with BN-PN’s mono-ethnicism.Have a bit of faith in Malaysians, they are many. They are waiting for signs of life inside the coalition. Easier to rekindle love with tired friends than to win votes from the cynical.Second, take a deep breath, allow the corruption investigating pendulum to swing as it may, and accept its aftermath.Four years in power does invite misbehaviour and Pakatan cannot break with tradition everywhere in the world. Many in the administration did their job, and some veered from the path. BN of old’s problem was not that it had no corruption, but that it was adamant corruption evaded it despite decades in power. No leaders of parties or coalitions are above the seduction of greed.The people do not expect angels but they cannot condone those who protect the wolves in the herd.Third, in campaigns speak less about corruption and who is stealing how much, let the national press and social media play it out. Talk more about achievements in the last four years. Positive campaigning looks soft but lasts longer.About spots and stripesUnfortunately, Pakatan is bent on its trajectory. To compete in the nonsense its competitor thrives in. To stay second in a race tailor-made for BN-PN. To hope to beat the master at his own game.Futile is this method but when one is convinced in being a hammer, all problems look like nails.These are not fun days for progressives. Seeing enemies at the gate and the expected ally to be lost at sea like Odysseus.* This is the personal opinion of the columnist.
You May Also Like