Malaysia
Perak water pact safeguards Penang with zero upfront capital, CM tells Lim Guan Eng
Thursday, 19 Nov 2026 12:00 PM MYT
GEORGE TOWN, Nov 19 — Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow has hit back at Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng over the Bulk Water Supply Agreement (BWSA) with Perak, defending its RM8.4 billion capacity charge as a deferred reimbursement model for a dedicated treatment facility that requires zero upfront capital from Penang.Chow said the 40-year deal between Perbadanan Bekalan Air Pulau Pinang (PBAPP) and Prasarana Air dan Irigasi Perak (PAIP) to supply between 300 million and 500 million litres per day (MLD) was debated in the state assembly and approved by 98 per cent of voting shareholders at PBA Holdings Bhd's (PBAHB) extraordinary general meeting on Nov 12."It is wholly irresponsible for Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng to dismiss the explanations that have been given repeatedly and continue to mislead the public over the BWSA between Perak and Penang,” Chow said in a statement today.Explaining the financial mechanics, Chow said the 500 MLD plant carries a baseline construction cost of RM3 billion, which totals RM8.4 billion once four decades of commercial interest, ongoing maintenance, and asset renewals are factored in."The capacity charge totalling RM8.4 billion over 40 years is a deferred payment to reimburse the construction costs of a plant built specifically to supply water to Penang,” he said."In return, Perak will bear full responsibility for construction and financing risks, as well as infrastructure maintenance and upgrades.”Chow stressed that the overall RM24.6 billion contract strictly separates the fixed RM8.4 billion availability charge from a distinct RM16.2 billion variable consumption fee.Dismissing claims that Penang would pay full freight for non-delivered water, he noted that "PBAPP only needs to pay supply charges based on the amount of water actually supplied that meets the quality standards agreed upon beforehand,” with PAIP liable for liquidated damages on supply shortfalls.The contract also allows PBAPP to walk away without further liability if breaches go unremedied, or exit via a discounted lump-sum formula.Addressing objections from five dissenting PBAHB directors, Chow said the entire board recognized the imperative of securing external supply.With state demand projected to breach 1,100 MLD by 2032 and existing surface sources fully tapped by 2030, Chow warned that "when all surface water sources in Penang are fully utilised by 2030, the state will no longer have new raw water sources.”He further noted that building an equivalent desalination plant would cost over RM25 billion.Chow was responding to Lim's statement yesterday questioning how the public interest was protected by an agreement that obligates Penang to pay RM210 million annually "even when not a single drop of treated water is supplied”.
You May Also Like