Malaysia
Lim Guan Eng questions RM210m annual Perak water payment, warns Penang tariffs could surge past RM7
Wednesday, 18 Nov 2026 11:21 AM MYT
GEORGE TOWN, Nov 18 — Bagan MP Lim Guan Eng has launched a scathing critique of Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow and state exco member Zairil Khir Johari, accusing the state leadership of disappointing residents by refusing to justify a 40-year water pact that requires Penang to pay Perak RM210 million annually, even if zero treated water is delivered.In a statement today, the former Penang chief minister revealed that the total financial exposure under the Northern Perak Water Supply Scheme amounts to at least RM24.6 billion over four decades beginning March 31, 2032.The mammoth commitment comprises RM8.4 billion in fixed capacity charges and an estimated RM16.2 billion in variable volumetric supply charges."This shocking revelation of PBAPP, a PBAH wholly-owned subsidiary, paying a mandatory RM 210 million annually despite getting nothing in return was exposed by 5 independent directors at PBA Holdings Bhd(PBAH) Extraordinary General Meeting on 12.11.2026,” he said.The contentious deal triggered internal dissent within the board of PBA Holdings Bhd (PBAH), the listed parent entity of state water operator Perbadanan Bekalan Air Pulau Pinang (PBAPP). Five of PBAH’s 12 directors, whom Lim described as seasoned and experienced professionals, formally recorded their objections to the off-take agreement during an extraordinary general meeting on Nov 12.The dissenting bloc, comprising Datuk Brian Tan Guan Hooi, Lim Eng Huat, Nor Hatina Md Salleh, Lim Seang Lee, and Raja Azmi Raja Nazuddin, raised serious alarms that PBAPP remains contractually saddled with the RM210 million annual capacity levy regardless of whether Perak delivers the contracted 300 million litres of treated water daily, or supplies nothing at all.Beyond the fixed RM8.4 billion commitment, Lim cautioned that escalating supply charges could trigger punishing tariff hikes for Penang domestic and industrial consumers. While the opening base tariff is set at RM1.70 per cubic metre, contractual escalations project the rate to rise to RM7.21 per cubic metre across the concession timeline. End-user tariffs could absorb an additional RM1 per cubic metre to cover internal operational costs, with rates potentially surging beyond the RM7.21 ceiling following a scheduled contract review after 22 years.Lim noted that while steep consumption tariffs could be contested on pricing merits, "at least we are paying for something” physically received.The core defect of the transaction, he argued, is an unconditional capacity penalty that leaves Penang taxpayers liable to pay hundreds of millions annually for non-existent water.Condemning the state administration for compromising public interest through an unbalanced commercial framework, Lim demanded full transparency from the chief minister."This is an unequal agreement to the people of Penang that is irrational, contrary to sound logic and opposite to not only good governance but also responsible leadership,” Lim said.He warned that refusing to account for the lopsided arrangement will severely undermine public confidence in the state administration as the staggering financial liability becomes widely understood across Penang.
You May Also Like