FRANKFURT, Feb 8 — German banks are seeking to blunt any fresh US sanctions against Russia so they can continue existing business with Russian clients, according to an internal briefing paper prepared by a financial industry lobby group.
The risk of new restrictions on doing business with Russia has risen since the Democratic Party won control of the US House of Representatives. New anti-Moscow measures could jeopardise funding for a multi-billion dollar gas pipeline between Germany and Russia.
In response, lenders in Europe’s largest economy have ratcheted up their lobbying efforts with US lawmakers and government officials, warning that current proposals to sanction major Russian banks would be so expansive that they could disrupt global markets.
“In their current form, the proposed bills would no longer just target the Russian President and oligarchs with close ties to Putin, but would effectively place an embargo against the Russian Federation,” according to an extract from the document prepared by the Association of German Banks.
“International financial institutions which already operate in Russia would face new sanctions with massive business and compliance challenges.”
The three-page paper calls for exceptions to be made which would allow “German banks and companies to complete business that cannot be unwound easily”.
The document, dated Dec. 3 2018, outlines key points for bankers to raise with US officials. It reflects the consensus view of the association, which represents 180 banks, including Deutsche Bank, Commerzbank and foreign lenders with units in Germany, such as Italy’s Unicredit .
The €9.5 billion (US$10.78 billion) Nord Stream 2 project, which seeks to channel gas from Russia directly to Germany under the Baltic Sea, is not mentioned in the document but its future lies at the heart of the renewed lobbying push.
“Nord Stream is the elephant in the room,” said one person with direct knowledge of the matter.
The pipeline project, which is majority owned by Russian energy giant Gazprom, plans to tap lenders this year, a spokesman for Nord Stream 2 told Reuters. He did not comment on the risk of new sanctions.
Russian news agency TASS quoted Nord Stream 2’s finance chief Paul Corcoran saying it was in discussions with export credit agencies and wanted to raise around €6 billion.
But lenders will not want to run afoul of any US sanctions.
German companies are already coming under pressure to distance themselves from Nord Stream. US President Donald Trump has said the pipeline will make Germany “captive” to Russia and last month, the US Ambassador to Germany sent a letter to companies involved in Nord Stream warning that they could face sanctions if they stick with it.
Gazprom declined to comment.
A ricochet effect
Last month, Germany’s Foreign Minister Heiko Maas told companies his government would try to protect them from potentially “massive collateral damage” if Washington levies further restrictions on Russia.
Almost five years of US and European sanctions, imposed after Russia’s 2014 annexation of Crimea, have already damaged economic ties between Germany and Russia.
Trade between the two countries was worth €57 billion in the first 11 months of last year, more than Germany’s trade with Japan and Canada combined but a way off the €71 billion recorded in the same period of 2013, the year before a wave of sanctions was introduced.
German banks are still among the most exposed international lenders to Russia with outstanding claims of nearly US$7 billion in the third quarter of 2018, according to figures from the Bank for International Settlements, but that is less than a third of the US$22.5 billion recorded for the same period in 2013.
The newly elected US congress is expected to move swiftly to bring new sanctions against Moscow.
Republican Senator Lindsey Graham introduced a bill in August called the “Defending American Security from Kremlin Aggression Act”, which proposes sanctions against big Russian banks and the country’s energy sector.
The German bankers’ attempt to moderate such moves comes at a delicate time for the country’s largest lender, Deutsche Bank. It faces renewed scrutiny from Congress over its most prominent customer – President Donald Trump – and its own past dealings with Russia.
Deutsche declined to comment on its role in any lobbying
Martin Zielke, the chief executive of Commerzbank, Germany’s second-largest listed bank, has met with Treasury officials and members of Congress in recent months to argue for leniency, according to two Washington-based sources.
Commerzbank declined to comment. Both it and Deutsche Bank have subsidiaries in Russia with a combined workforce of more than 1,000 employees.
Further entreaties are expected to be made by top German bank executives in the run-up to April, when finance officials and bankers gather for the annual Spring meeting of the International Monetary Fund IMF and World Bank in Washington DC.
Senator Chris Van Hollen told Reuters in a telephone interview he planned to reintroduce a Russian sanctions bill in the coming months, or even sooner.
The Democrat, who this week called for a Senate investigation of allegations of money laundering involving Deutsche Bank, said that sanctions should be designed to limit “to the extent possible, any ricochet on European banks and others.”
“However, there is usually going to be some fallout and some repercussions for European banks given that there are these relationships,” he said. — Reuters